:strip_icc():format(webp)/saltwater-aquarium-nitrate-reducing-products-2925796-78fc0d9101714d86b9cea183ded5ffed.jpg)
The Spruce Pets / Lecia Landis
Nitrate reducing products can greatly benefit a saltwater aquarium by removing nitrate buildup from the end of the nitrogen cycle. The nitrogen cycle takes the primary fish waste of ammonia and converts it into a less toxic compound. At high levels, nitrate can cause serious disease in your fish, so testing your levels should be part of your routine water quality evaluation.
Our top pick in saltwater aquarium nitrate reducing products is SeaChem Purigen. With a higher initial investment, Purigen is effective, reusable and easy to tell when it needs to be recharged. Keep it in your fluidized bed or a mesh bag in your filter for best use.
Our Top Picks
Best Overall
Seachem Purigen Organic Filtration Resin
Can be reused/recharge for multiple uses
Color-changing when used up
Can replace carbon filter
Can be messy
Requires method of retaining resin materials such as mesh bag
Expensive
SeaChem Purigen is a synthetic absorption resin made up of a macroporous polymer. It is our top choice since it is easy to use, can be reused and changes color as it absorbs various chemicals in the water, including nitrate. It comes as a bag of small beads, so it is recommended to be kept in a mesh bag or fluidized bed (see our recommendation for a fluidized bed below – link?). Some Purigen products come ready-to-go in a bag. It is more expensive, but you can get multiple uses out of one purchase, depending on how much material needs to be absorbed.
Purigen needs to be replaced regularly, but you will know when depending on the color of the material. Starting out white or off white, the polymer will change color depending on what is being scrubbed from the water. After the material is no longer white, it will need to be replaced or recharged. You may get a few uses out of one bag by recharging it in a mild bleach solution. Some hobbyists use Purigen instead of carbon and it will act similarly, deactivating any water-based medication added to your tank. Purigen is safe for use in both saltwater and freshwater systems.
Available Sizes: 100ml, 500 ml | Gallons Treated: 1ml per 1 gallon | Longevity: 4 to 6 months (depends on bioload)
Another Great Option
DrTims NP-Active Pearls for Nutrient Control
Best researched product
Very safe for fish
Can replace carbon filtration
Requires protein skimmer or additional filter
Expensive
Dr. Tim’s entire product line comes heavily researched and tested, including their Aquatic NP-Active Pearls. This product works by providing surface area for nitrifying bacteria and contains a polymer that absorbs nitrate and phosphate from the water. It is a more expensive product and needs to be housed in a fluidized bed or mesh container within the filter.
It is critical that these beads be placed in an area where you can see them. Dr. Tim’s Aquatic NP-Active Pearls will slowly degrade over time and will need to be replaced. It can take a few weeks for you to appreciate any visual difference in your algae levels, but your water quality testing will allow you to determine your most effective dose.
Available Sizes: 450 ml | Gallons Treated: 150 gallons | Longevity: 6 to 9 months
Best Budget
Seachem Denitrate
Simple to use
Chemical-free
No additional additives or products needed
Paying extra for fancy rocks
If you’re looking for a budget method to remove your nitrates, consider SeaChem Denitrate. These fancy rocks essentially provide anaerobic housing for denitrifying bacteria that break down nitrate into nitrogen gas. They are much slower acting than the other products listed in this review, therefore they may be better suited for a minor, long-term solution to higher nitrate levels.
For best results, SeaChem Denitrate media will require specific water flow. Water flowing too slowly over these rocks will lose its bacteria due to lack of food, but too high water flow can cause incomplete conversion to nitrate gas. It can take some fiddling with your water flow to have this media work correctly. If you already have live rock in your tank, this product works very similarly, but will come into more contact with the water if placed in a filter.
Available Sizes: 1.7 pounds | Gallons Treated: 100 gallons | Longevity: Several years
Best Long-Term Nitrate Reducer
Kolar Labs Bio-Pellets
Safe for fish and corals
Easy to use
Works on nitrates and phosphates
Needs to be in fluidized bed
Kolar Labs Metabolix Bio-Pellets are made with PHA resin and derived from corn. They are very safe for fish and invertebrates and can be used in both freshwater and saltwater aquariums. Since they are an inert resin, they require an area of high water flow in order to be most effective, most commonly in a fluidized bed. If you do not have a fluidized bed, they can be added to your filtration in a contained mesh bag but will not be as effective.
The Kolar Labs Metabolix Bio-Pellets are made to absorb both nitrate and phosphate which can greatly increase your algae levels. However, this product is one of the most expensive on this list and will need to be replaced overtime. Consumers note that when first added, these beads can make the water very cloudy. The manufacturer recommends soaking the pellets in tank water for 24 hours to prevent floating and remove the dust prior. Overuse of these pellets can cause the water to become cloudy, so it is important to keep an eye on how much you use.
Available Sizes: 10.58 ounces; 1 pound; 1.32 pounds; 5 pounds | Gallons Treated: 1 cup per 50 gallons | Longevity: 4-6 months
Best Filtration Pad
PENN-PLAX Nitrate Reducer Media Pad
Easy to install
Can also provide mechanical filtration
Option to cut into cubes to add to fluidized bed
Cannot visually see when it is used up
For a fool proof method of nitrate removal, any aquarium owner can use the PENN-PLAX Nitrate Reducer Filter Media Pad. Like any other filter, this pad can be cut to the correct size of your filter and will absorb nitrates in addition to acting as a mechanical filter. It will become inactive over time, and it is recommended to be replaced every 4-6 weeks. Thankfully, this product is very inexpensive and costs less than a lot of filter media out there.
For best results, the manufacturer recommends rinsing the filter pad prior to adding it to your tank. Since you may be replacing this filter media often, it is recommended to keep another, non-reactive pad in your filter at all times that will remain in your system for the life of your tank. You will need a sturdy sponge, such as the Aquaneat Aquarium Bio Sponge, that can also be cut to any specific size.
If you want, you can also cut up this pad into small cubes and add it to your fluidized bed like many of the other products on this list. It will not break down like some of the other products, but will need to be replaced to keep up with its nitrate-binding capabilities.
Available Sizes: 10 x 18 x 1 inches | Gallons Treated: Up to 50 gallons | Longevity: 4-6 weeks
Best Nitrate and Phosphate Reducer
Red Sea NO3:PO4-X
Treats both high nitrate and phosphate issues
Utilizes bacterial colonies already in system
Flammable
Requires protein skimmer or additional filter
Red Sea NO3:PO4-X is specifically designed to treat both nitrate and phosphate overload in coral tanks with algae issues. It can be used in other systems but was specifically designed for use in saltwater coral aquariums. Red Sea NO3:PO4-X works by providing additional supplementation for heterotrophic bacteria that utilize nitrogen and phosphate as a food source thereby naturally removing it from your system. However, with the supplementation of these bacteria comes a secondary bacterial bloom. Therefore, it is highly recommended to use this product with a protein skimmer to remove the additional proteinaceous bacterial load.
Keep in mind that the main active ingredient, ethanol, is highly flammable, so store this product in a safe place and keep it away from children. This product works very similarly to the “vodka method” to reduce nitrates. The ethanol in vodka also promotes bacterial growth for these hardworking bacteria.
Available Sizes: 16 ounces | Gallons Treated: 1-3ml per 25 gallons | Longevity: Varies, check expiration date on label
Best Bacteria
Dr. Tim's Aquatics One and Only Live Nitrifying Bacteria
Can be used in new or established tanks
Comes in a wide variety of sizes, suitable for both small and large aquariums
Odor free
Safe for most fish
Bacterial products may not work in your system
Nitrifying bacteria convert your fishes’ primary waste product, ammonia, into nitrate, as part of its biological filtration. There are many bacterial products available on the market claiming to “instantly start” your biological filtration by providing you with the bacteria necessary for your tank to survive. However, many of these claims are false and have shown in independent tests to be completely ineffective. It is just not that simple to drop a bacterial bomb into your tank and expect it to do all the heavy lifting.
Dr. Tim’s Aquatics One and Only Live Nitrifying Bacteria was the one product we tested in our hospital that actually shortened the cycling period of our brand-new systems. Rather than 5-6 weeks, the system we tried only took 4.5 weeks. Is it magic and will solve all your cycling problems? Absolutely not. Will it give your system and small and safe boost. Yes; just don’t expect miracles.
Available Sizes: 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64, 128 ounces | Gallons Treated: 10 ml per 10 gallons | Longevity: N/A
Final Verdict
Our best choice for saltwater aquarium nitrate reducing products is SeaChem Purigen. Although it may seem expensive, it is easy to use, changing color as it becomes fully saturated with nitrates and can be recharged for multiple uses. Another great choice is Kolar Labs Metabolix Bio-Pellets. This is a more expensive product but works well to absorb nitrates and phosphates and is safe for both freshwater and saltwater systems.
How We Picked
As a private-practice fish veterinarian, I get lots of questions from my clients on how to improve their water quality. With high nitrates, we mainly recommend water changes rather than these above products. However, in farmland with high nitrates in their water already, these products can be very beneficial. With all the above categories, there is a product out there that can help. Depending on the client’s set up, we may recommend adding another media to their fluidized bed, occasionally liquid additive, or that easy to use absorbent pad.
With some of the products, I do not have firsthand experience, but thoroughly research everything using product reviews and any product research publications.
What to Look for in a Nitrate Reducing Product
Signs The Product Is Working
Various nitrate reducing products will utilize different methods to indicate if they are working. Some will change color, while others will slowly shrink. If you are unsure about how a product will be used in your system, you will need to continuously check your nitrate levels. Check out our nitrate test kit recommendation below.
Application Frequency
Depending on the product you choose, you may need to continually dose your system or just add as needed. Be sure to read the instructions carefully and take dosing into any financial considerations.
Additional Equipment
Some products work by boosting bacterial colonies, which can cause other problems with your water quality and biomass. Protein skimmers are a common feature of saltwater aquariums, but may need to be added for some of the recommended products and cleaned more frequently.
Reusing Various Products
Some of the recommended products can be reused if they are recharged. Some freshwater products actually use saltwater to be recharged, and therefore are not able to be utilized in marine tanks. Some products can be recharged in a mild bleach solution per the manufacturers instructions, making them a better investment.
Saltwater vs. Freshwater
Read all the fine print before purchasing a nitrate reducer. Some products are very specific to only one type of system. As mentioned previously, some products are recharged using salt water, making them only effective in freshwater systems.
More Products We Recommend
Reef Octopus Classic Protein Skimmer: Adding bacteria-producing products to your system, such as many of the products above, can lead to foam or cloudy water. For best results, a protein skimmer can be used to remove proteinaceous products simply and effectively. Most of these products, including our recommended Reef Octopus, require a sump setup for best use. Please keep in mind that many complaints about protein skimmers are caused by user error, so please do your research, read the set-up materials carefully and ask for help from a professional if necessary.
NYOS Nitrate Test Kit: Testing nitrate levels is critical for both saltwater and freshwater aquariums. The NYOS Nitrate Test kit requires a few additional steps compared to other kits out there, but the results are worth it. This kit comes with an easy to read results colorimetric chart and is worth the slightly higher price.
QANVEE Fluidized Moving Bed Filter: Most nitrate reducing products work best with high water flow, coming into contact with a high volume of tank water. Therefore, you will need a fluidized bed, such as the QANVEE Fluidized Moving Bed Filter. This filter is very easy to set up, includes all the filter media, which only takes up half of the volume of the canister in order to best function. You can add in some of the bead-like nitrate reducers to this filter, but be sure to remove some of the included media for best function. The only thing not included is an aquarium pump, but here’s a great one to make this kit complete, Uniclife Aquarium Air Pump Dual Outlet.
-
Can you reduce nitrates in saltwater aquariums without changing the water?
There are many mechanisms available to a saltwater aquarium owner to remove harmful nitrates from their aquarium system. Nitrate reduction without water changes is critical to those hobbyists who do not have great access to clean source water or lack the physical ability to heft large buckets of salt water.
Keep in mind that water changes remove more than just nitrate. Biological products from your fish, including hormones for stress and reproduction can also build up and may need to be removed through water changes. Unfortunately, there are no tests available for these on the commercial market.
-
Do aquarium plants reduce nitrates?
In freshwater systems, yes indeed, plants can reduce nitrate levels. However, most live plants do not survive in saltwater systems. For saltwater systems, macroalgae can help remove nitrates from your system in a similar fashion.
Most of these filtration units are set up in a refugium. This is a separate chamber of your filtration that houses macroalgae and some invertebrates, if desired. The amount of plant or algae will help with nitrate levels, but do not expect it to do all the work unless you have a considerable amount of macroalgae or plants.
"Macroalgae may present an interesting option for some hobbyists, especially considering the recent trends towards natural and low-maintenance systems," says Dr. Ashley Emanuele. "The term macroalgae is applied to a large group of multicellular seaweeds, and they are often maintained in a refugium or sump. Adding additional light and powerheads to the refugium allows the algae to act as a natural sink for nitrate products, similar to the way plants function in freshwater aquaria." -
Does charcoal reduce nitrate levels in an aquarium?
Activated carbon, used as a water purifier in both saltwater and freshwater aquariums, does not impact nitrate levels in either type of system. Carbon will remove chloramine, carbon, tannins, and phenols, but will not remove any nitrogen products, including ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate.
-
How do you know if a nitrate reducing product is working?
Depending on the product you are using, some may change color to demonstrate that they are working. However, the best method of verifying nitrate levels is to test your water chemistry using a liquid-based test kit. Be sure to read all testing instructions carefully, shake your testing bottles thoroughly, use them regularly, and replace them every year.
Why Trust The Spruce Pets?
This story was written by Dr. Jessie Sanders, an aquatic veterinarian with over 10 years of experience working with pet fish veterinarian. Sanders is familiar with most of the products available to fish owners. Although these nitrate reducing products are not typically recommended, she has received first-hand positive results and feedback on these products from her clients.
We consulted with Dr. Ashley Emanuele, who is a Certified Aquatic Veterinarian.